- The AI Dealer | The #1 AI & Tech Guide for Car Dealers
- Posts
- The $9,000 Secret Every Car Dealer Needs to Know
The $9,000 Secret Every Car Dealer Needs to Know
How mastering objections can put thousands in your pocket
Bryan Pascual
August 31, 2025
Most deals are won or lost at the moment of the objection. When dealers improve how they handle objections, the math gets exciting fast.
The numbers
A typical salesperson works 60 to 80 opportunities per month and closes 15 to 20 percent.
A realistic improvement of 3 to 5 percentage points from focused objection practice can add 30 to 40 extra cars per year for one person.
With an average commission of about 300 dollars per car, that is 9,000 to 12,000 dollars more income per salesperson each year.
At the store level, a ten person team at 2,000 dollars average front and back gross per car can add 600,000 to 800,000 dollars in annual gross.
This same approach also boosts results for finance managers, service departments, and BDC teams. Finance can practice rate and product objections. Service can practice estimate and wait time conversations. BDC can drill first contact calls and can also use chat to refine scripts and DMs.
Why instant objection handling works
You hear pressure and concerns in a safe setting, not with a live buyer.
You build muscle memory for clear value statements and smart questions.
You get immediate coaching so each rep improves daily.
Step by step: use voice for back and forth practice
Open your AI tool with voice
Open your assistant on mobile or desktop. Tap the microphone to start a voice conversation.Set the ground rules for the role play
Tell the AI to act like a real shopper. Ask it to keep replies short and stay firm when you give weak answers.Feed the scenario details
Give the payment target, vehicle, condition, and context so the practice feels real.Ask for escalating pressure
Tell the AI to stack common objections such as price, payment, trade value, credit, spouse, and online comparisons.Get coaching after each turn
Ask it to score your reply from 1 to 10, show what you did well, and give one improvement you should try on the next turn.Repeat with variations
Change the payment, change the vehicle, switch from cash to finance, switch from retail to subprime, add a trade, and keep drilling.Save your best lines
When a line lands, ask the AI to save it to a personal cheat sheet you can review before the next shift.
Voice prompt you can use right now
Copy this into your AI tool and say it out loud. Replace the brackets.
Prompt
Act as a shopper who is serious but skeptical. We are discussing a [year] [make] [model] that is [new or used]. My customer target payment is [monthly price] with [down payment amount] down and credit is [credit tier]. Use short two sentence replies. Start with a payment objection. If I give a weak answer, add a tougher objection such as I saw it cheaper online, I need to ask my spouse, the payment is too high, or the trade is too low. After each of my replies give me a score from 1 to 10, one sentence on what I did well, and one sentence on how to improve. Keep going until I ask to stop.
Examples to swap in
2021 Toyota Camry used, target payment 375 dollars, 2,000 down, fair credit
2019 Ford F 150 used, target payment 450 dollars, 1,000 down, good credit
2024 Honda CR V new, target payment 520 dollars, 3,000 down, prime credit
Department playbook ideas
Finance managers
Practice rate objections, warranty value, GAP, and product bundling.
Add constraints such as bank approval limits and term caps.
Ask for coaching on compliant language and clear benefit framing.
Service department
Practice estimate shock, parts delay, and ride request conversations.
Ask for language that sets expectations and keeps CSI strong.
BDC
Drill first call scripts with voice and refine copy in chat.
Generate three text variations for no response leads and compare.
Role play cross channel moves from Marketplace to phone to store visit.
Bottom line
Better objection handling is not theory. It is a daily habit that can add 30 to 40 more cars per year for one salesperson and 9,000 to 12,000 dollars of extra commission. Multiply that across your floor and the impact on store gross is real.
Test this out for just 15 minutes a day over the next week. Did your closing rate improve? Hit reply and let me know, I might feature your story in the next issue.
– Bryan
Want more?
Here’s a full list of 50 proven prompts that dealers and salespeople can use daily.